I'm Super! The "Superfrontal Gyrus" is the Seat of Self-Awareness!
The New Scientist has a horrible article on a new fMRI study :
Watching the brain 'switch off' self-awarenessSeriously, the "superfrontal" gyrus does not exist, perhaps NewScientist.com writer Gaia Vince meant "superior frontal gyrus." And I doubt that the subjects turned into robots when the card flipping and musical sequences were rapid. I'll read the original paper in Neuron and report back.
. . .
The team conducted a series of experiments to pinpoint the brain activity associated with introspection and that linked to sensory function. They found that the brain assumes a robotic functionality when it has to concentrate all its efforts on a difficult, timed task – only becoming "human" again when it has the luxury of time.
. . .
Goldberg found that when the sensory stimulus was shown slowly, and when a personal emotional response was required, the volunteers showed activity in the superfrontal gyrus – the brain region associated with self-awareness-related function.
But when the card flipping and musical sequences were rapid, there was no activity in the superfrontal gyrus, despite activity in the sensory cortex and related structures.
. . .
This is definitely one for BAD Neuro-Journalism!
Thanks to Elliot for the link.
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
1 Comments:
For shame. Everybody knows it's known as the "super-dee-duper frontalicious gyrus."
FMRI stuff is breeding another bumper crop of science a-la "My driveway is wet, so therefore goblins must have emptied thousand of squirt guns on it. Don't you dare suggest it rained! After all, I have pictures that suggest it could have been goblins!"
Nice post. Bad article.
Post a Comment
<< Home